| |
From a review by Roger Ebert:
|
|
Charlie Chaplin's "The Great Dictator" (1940)
came some 12 years after the introduction of sound, but
it was Chaplin's first all-talking picture, and the first
in which we heard the Little Tramp speak. The dialogue
turned out to be his last words; Chaplin never used the
Tramp character again after this film.
In a way, the Tramp's heartfelt closing plea for peace
and human brotherhood is spoken by Chaplin himself, stepping
out of character to make a personal statement on the eve
of the war with Hitler. The speech does not fit into the
fabric of the rest of the film (as many critics noted
at the time), but the passage of years has made it seem
uncannily appropriate.
Chaplin conceived and filmed "The Great Dictator"
during a period when an accommodation with Hitler was
still thought possible in some quarters; indeed, he must
have been filming when Neville Chamberlain went to Munich.
But Chaplin himself had no such optimism, and his portrait
of Adenoid Hynkel, dictator of Tomania, was among the
first declarations of war on Hitler. The film also prophesied
the persecution of the Jews, and the scenes of storm troopers
terrorizing the Ghetto were thought at the time to go
too far. What a sad joke that seems today.
The film itself is filled with sad, pathetic little jokes;
this is Chaplin's most serious, most tragic, most human
work. He did not find Hitler at all funny, needless to
say, and so although he uses his own comic genius to inspire
the movie, the comedy is never neutral. It is jugular,
as he creates a Hynkel who is a vain, strutting buffoon,
given to egomaniacal rages and ridiculous posturing. Charlie
never for a moment allows us to laugh with Hynkel, but
only at him, and Hynkel thus becomes the only totally
unsympathetic character Chaplin has ever played. To balance
him, Chaplin also plays the part of a Jewish barber who
happens to be Hynkel's exact double (and who also happens
to look exactly like the Little Tramp).
There are some good belly laughs in the movie, most of
them involving a state visit by Belzoni Napoloni, dictator
of the neighbouring nation of Bacteria. As played by Jack
Oakie, Napoloni is a loud, cheerful, idiotic clown whose
natural zest for a good time cuts right through Hynkel's
phoney dignity.
It's during the Oakie scenes that we get many of the film's
most famous comedy moments: the futile attempt to seat
Napoloni on a very low chair, so Hynkel can tower over
him; the negotiations during the banquet, when Hynkel
says he will destroy his enemies just like this (and attempts
to rip apart a handful of spaghetti, but can't), and of
course the classic barber-chair scene, in which each dictator
tries to pump himself higher than the other.
There are also immortal moments of Chaplin pantomime.
He shaves a customer in time to classic music. As the
Jewish barber, dressed in the stolen uniform of the dictator,
he nonchalantly reviews "his" troops and then
sits in a folding chair that collapses, causing complete
confusion. And, as the dictator, he does the famous ballet
with the world globe painted on a balloon.
Glenn Abel, The Hollywood Reporter:
|
|
Charles Chaplin had a problem with authority. Policemen,
bosses, bureaucrats -- the powerful and the pompous all
had it coming. The Little Tramp usually had his way with
them all before the lights came up.
In 1938, with the winds of war swirling in Europe, Chaplin
took on his biggest target -- the swaggering former tramp
from Austria who lorded over Germany and its Nazi Party.
The satire would be called "The Great Dictator."
It seemed, at the time, a fair fight. The most popular
man in the world vs. Adolph Hitler, leader of a reeling
nation. Just two years before, in "Modern Times,"
Chaplin had tackled capitalism as personified by Henry
Ford, a union-busting admirer of Hitler. Chaplin's weapon
of choice was comedy, and it was feared.
"A comic David had arisen to fight Goliath,"
film critic Stanley Kauffmann recalls thinking, joyously,
at the time. Today, Charles Chaplin the man remains as
closely linked to his leftist politics as Charlie Chaplin
the comedian is to his derby hat, cane and moustache.
Nazi propagandists attacked Chaplin, saying he was Jewish
(he wasn't, but he refused to deny the claim). Chaplin's
homeland, Britain, vowed to ban the upcoming film, hoping
not to anger Hitler. Chaplin was under pressure in his
adopted home of the United States not to make the film,
which he would have to finance himself via United Artists.
Chaplin pressed ahead after a message of support came
from President Franklin D. Roosevelt himself.
The film remains controversial to this day. Some historians
have criticized the movie's mix of humour and real-life
horror. That appears to be a minority view. "Comedy
is the greatest way to attack anything like a totalitarian
regime -- they can't stand it," author Ray Bradbury
says.
Chaplin played two roles: the ridiculous-but-deadly dictator
Adenoid Hynkel (Hitler) and a Jewish barber who was a
dead-ringer for the despot. Actor Jack Oakie turns up
as a buffoonish Mussolini.
Although the film was banned in many parts of Europe,
it became Chaplin's biggest box-office success. (The tagline
was "The world laughs again.") Wartime records
showed that Hitler saw the film not once, but twice.
Chaplin himself had doubts about the film and almost withheld
it from release when Hitler invaded France. Had he known
the extent of the Nazis' evil, Chaplin said later, he
never would have made The Great Dictator.
The film stars Chaplin as Hynkel and the barber, Paulette
Goddard as Hannah, Jack Oakie as Napaloni, Reginald Gardiner
as Schultz, Henry Daniell as Garbitsch and Billy Gilbert
as Field Marshal Herring, an incompetent advisor to Hynkel.
Chaplin stars in a double role as the Jewish barber (the
Tramp in all but name) and the fascist dictator, clearly
modeled on Adolf Hitler.
The names of the aides of Adenoid Hynkel are similar to
those of Hitler. Garbitsch (pronounced "garbage"),
the right hand man of Hynkel is very similar to that of
Joseph Goebbels and Field Marshal Herring was clearly
modelled after the Luftwaffe chief, Hermann Goering while
beyond doubt the "Diggaditchie" of Bacteria,
Benzino Napaloni, was modeled after Il Duce, Benito Mussolini.
Much of the film is taken up by Hynkel and Napaloni arguing
over the fate of Osterlich. Originally, Mussolini was
opposed to the German takeover since he saw Austria as
a buffer-state between Germany and Italy. This conflict
is almost forgotten today given Italy's support for Germany
during World War II.
|
|