Keswick Film Club - Reviews - Lemon Tree

You are viewing the old version of our website.

Please visit our current website for all the latest information.

Reviews - Lemon Tree

Lemon Tree

Reviewed By John Stakes

Lemon Tree
Lemon Tree
The Arab-Israeli conflict is rarely out of the media spotlight and forever in the collective conscience of people around the world. Israeli Director Eran Riklis’ take on this troubled region was to focus on the real life problems of Salma Zidane, a lonely Palestine widow whose beloved family lemon grove lay close to the Israeli border with the West Bank.

The grove had never previously been used or perceived as a cover for terrorists and a possible threat to Israeli national security until Salma finds she has new next door neighbours in the form of the coldly calculating Israeli Defence Minister and his beautiful but no less lonely wife Mira.

The Israelis decide to perimeter-fence Salma’s grove and construct a look-out tower having ordered her to keep out. Salma hires a Palestinian divorce lawyer Ziad Daud to take her appeal against this decision through the Israeli court system and ultimately to its Supreme Court. Mira’s sympathy for Salma’s plight grows as the lemons die and the case progresses, and the two women finally come face to face on the steps of the court on the dreadful day of judgement. Salma’s appeal all but fails when the court rules that the grove need not be uprooted but that half the trees must be severely pruned.

In the meantime we have been shown the gargantuan concrete wall in the course of construction by the Israelis along the border with the West Bank. The wall reaches the boundary of the Defence Minister’s home entirely obliterating their view of Salma’s grove just as her appeal is lost as a result of which Mira decides to leave her husband and home.

The decision to cast Hiam Abbass (last seen as the mother of a Syrian illegal immigrant in The Visitor last autumn) as Salma was inspired, her own life reflecting the conflict and its human impact. She was born in Nazareth of Palestinian parents in 1960 after her parents became refugees in Palestine when the State of Israel was created. In the 1967 seven days’ war she had family and friends in Lebanon and Syria who were fighting the Israeli neighbours she grew up with. She eventually moved to London when she felt uncomfortable living in Palestine under the Israelis and now speaks four languages including Arabic her mother tongue.

Throughout Lemon Tree Salma remains dignified, even serene. She scarcely needed to speak as Abbass perfectly captured in her face Salma’s inner melancholy and eventual despair. The film was more an essay on the frustrating consequences of the failure to communicate with one’s enemies than an overt political drama, with Riklis determined to be even-handed throughout. But there was political significance everywhere and particularly as the lemons fell from the un-watered trees. The final tracking shot as the camera moved through Mira’s home when the blinds were drawn to reveal the monstrosity of the wall a few yards away over which the camera climbed to look down on Salma’s decimated lemon grove was heart wrenchingly powerful.

A magnificent film and a worthy festival entry.

Back To Film Page

Find A Film

Search over 1375 films in the Keswick Film Club archive.

Film Festival

Festival Logo

27 Feb - 1 Mar 2020


KFC is friends with Caldbeck Area Film Society and Brampton Film Club and members share benefits across all organisations


Keswick Film Club won the Best New Film Society at the British Federation Of Film Societies awards in 2000.

Since then, the club has won Film Society Of The Year and awards for Best Programme four times and Best Website twice.

We have also received numerous Distinctions and Commendations in categories including marketing, programming and website.

Talking Pictures Talking Pictures The KFC Newsletter
Links Explore the internet with Keswick Film Club
Find Us On Facebook