Reviews - L'enfer
Reviewed By John Stakes
Chabrol is often described as the French Hitchcock. Both were fascinated by the destructive quality of obsession, jealousy and passion, and both were master craftsmen in the technique of drawing their audiences into the developing drama which usually climaxed in death.
L’Enfer stars Emmanuelle Béart as Nelly and François Cluzet as Paul, both young and recently married hoteliers on a large idyllic country estate. Their early married life up to when their son Julien first attends school was whisked through presumably because it was dramatically uneventful. They seem happily married, but a number of seemingly trivial incidents (a lost keepsake, a lingering smile and some missing hours) soon ignite Paul’s suspicions as to his wife’s fidelity.
From this point onwards it’s downhill all the way for Paul whose jealousy becomes obsessive and possessive. Nelly’s reassurances of fidelity fall on his deaf ears. Nelly is impossibly beautiful. The local garage proprietor Martineau is extraordinarily handsome so it is no surprise that Nelly’s casual dalliances with him quickly sow the seeds of doubt in Paul’s mind. Her sexuality is all too evident matched by an inability to control it so the now far from happy couple become locked in a downward spiral laden with, in theatrical terms, a tragic inevitability.
Paul’s psychological disintegration sees him restricting Nelly’s freedom of movement until finally he locks her in the bedroom and ties her to the bed where, in a deliberately ambiguous dénouement, we know not for certain whether he has killed her. In his deranged state Paul imagines his torment will never end but probably because he’s unable to recognise that he’s killed Nelly either from a sleeping tablet overdose or by nastier means.
There was much to admire in Chabrol’s style. As Paul quickly loses his sanity so the hotel changes from a laughter and happiness-filled venue to an eerily-lit soulless building with darkened recesses. Chabrol’s camera often lured us into rooms and manipulated our attention in true Hitchcockian manner. The point from which Paul lost his grip on reality was cleverly blurred making us unsure whether we were witnessing real events or creations of Paul’s imagination. Was the bizarre scene in the doctor’s surgery reality or fiction?
The portrayal of mental impairment is never an easy task and in the main Cluzet handled his descent into madness with conviction though at times his face seemed overly contorted and there was much eye-rolling. We were assisted by occasional voice-overs from his character in which he articulated his tortured thoughts. Everyone around Paul seemed to have a real zest for life and enjoyed each other’s company which served to heighten his self-alienation and the burden of his jealousy.
Béart expertly displayed Nelly’s full range of emotions from spoilt, pouty, school- girly manner, through coquettish luscious-lipped tease and loving wife to victim of mental and physical abuse. She deftly handled the ambiguity of her behaviour and her inability to avoid suspicion.
Whilst L’Enfer contained many acknowledgements of the genius of Hitchcock, some scenes lacked the master’s rigorous quality of construction and timing. The first half felt overly frenetic as we were pitch-forked in and out of scenes and only in the later scenes were tension and drama allowed to develop and with that both our empathy and sympathy.
And here’s a postscript to the L’Enfer saga. Research reveals yet another L’Enfer and starring Emmanuelle Béart again! It was made in 2005 by Danis Tanovic from a script by “Three Colours” Polish director Kryzstof Kieslowski. This time Béart as the wife is on the receiving end as it’s her husband who is having an affair which she knows about. Just deserts some might say!
Find A Film
Search over 1050 films in the Keswick Film Club archive.
Keswick Film Club has won the following British
Federation of Film Societies awards:
Best Website 2008
Best Website 2007
Film Society of The Year 2006
Best Programme 2005
Best Programme 2004
Best Programme 2002
Best Programme 2001
Best New Film Society 2000
plus 7 Distinctions and 4 Commendations
See All Awards
Links Explore the internet with Keswick Film Club